1 – 6 of 6
Blogger mathan said...

Great read.

Um, I don't really have anything sarcastic or mildly funny to say. I just enjoyed your piece.

Oh, wait. I enjoyed your piece and I can't remember the last time that happened.

Still got it.

July 15, 2007 at 2:07 AM

Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have a hard time understanding how you can possibly defend a guy like Sheffield who's been a cancer in every clubhouse he's ever been in. He plays "the victim" whenever he's the one pushing an agenda and is so transparent that I'm stunned anyone still shoves a microphone in his face.

I think you make some good points here and there, Cam, but by and large I violently disagree with this one.

July 15, 2007 at 6:32 AM

Anonymous Anonymous said...

The thing that irks me about all of this is how the media is quick to bash an outspoken athlete like Sheffield under the guise that's "everything's alllllllll right".

After all, how can there possibly be racism in a world where minorities can now eat at the Woolworth's diner counter and make $100M large playing a kid's game?

July 15, 2007 at 4:34 PM

Blogger Tom said...

The reason that people are attacking Sheffield partially falls under the Bonds' rule. Gary Sheffield is an famous mal-content who has a problem everywhere he goes, who's admitted to committing errors on purpose, and he's had a chip on his shoulder about Torre since last year's playoffs. And of all people to find confirmation, they go to 11-teams-in-16-years player Kenny Lofton. Then, to try and make a further point, they go to Joe Morgan... who would never ever say something bad about a black player (and there's nothing wrong with that... he's from an era when they still hadn't had a black manager in the game yet) who gives a standard Joe answer of "I'm not in the clubhouse so I can't say". Couldn't it just be, with those specific two guys, that Torre just treats assholes differently? It also makes it really tough when Sheff doesn't expand on what he got "called out" about.

The other problem is that it's nearly impossible for Torre to defend himself. Torre didn't want Sheffield on that team, he wanted Vlad. Everyone in the organization, except Steinbrenner, wanted Vlad. All Torre can really do is what he's doing: ignoring it and let it go away.

July 16, 2007 at 11:55 AM

Blogger Greg Wind said...

Sheff can say whatever he wants in my book. He's always interesting, he's been around long enough to have a valid opinion he and doesn't seem to say stuff just to kick up dirt. He's just speaking his mind without censoring himself. If a guy has established that as his style, the reaction to what he says is always going to be 100 times more telling than the original statement. In the name of being "objective" people will contort all kinds of "facts." Why don't they just say "I don't believe him" or something? He was being dispassionately subjective. If you can't manage the same, you might have an issue yourself. Maybe he was wrong, but you know who's going to prove that? Other people that stood in his shoes. Did I miss the outcry from former or current Yankees? (And I'm a Yankees fan.)

July 16, 2007 at 12:03 PM

Blogger Aaron C. said...

ALEX: Respectfully, your sentiments are absurd. Sheffield's a cancer in every clubhouse? He's been to the playoffs five straight years and his a WS ring.

TOM: You make some great points. Particularly about Joe Morgan, who famously was referenced in the late NL umpire Eric Gregg's autobiography as a player who'd look for calls under the guise of "helping out a brutha".

Sheffield's an easy, convenient villian, I agree, but sometimes even bad guys tell the truth.

GREG: Agreed. It's the media that's turned Sheffield's words into accusations of racism. This is not a story, but damn it, Sportscenter will sure try and make it one!

July 16, 2007 at 10:47 PM

You can use some HTML tags, such as <b>, <i>, <a>

Comment moderation has been enabled. All comments must be approved by the blog author.

You will be asked to sign in after submitting your comment.